Tyler Vestal got his start in Christian music performing with his mother, Sheri Vestal, in Rejoice! Rejoice! was initially a female trio. When Tyler joined, he sang bass and played piano.
Vestal joined Freedom Trio to sing baritone in 2012. In 2013, he joined Beyond The Ashes to sing baritone and play piano.
In 2015, he replaced Wayne Haun with Ernie Haase And Signature Sound to play piano.